PIP Alternatives 

Traditional Performance Improvement Plans often create more problems than they solve, damaging relationships and rarely leading to lasting change. Our evidence-based alternatives help organizations address performance issues while maintaining positive working relationships and achieving sustainable improvements.

 

Why Traditional PIPs Fall Short:

  • Create adversarial relationships between managers and employees
  • Focus on documenting problems rather than solving them
  • Often used as a legal process rather than a genuine improvement tool
  • Rarely address the underlying behavioral or environmental causes
  • Often signal to employees that termination is likely, creating a self-fulfilling prophecy
  • Put talented employees on the defensive instead of supporting growth
  • Create stress and anxiety that often worsens performance
  • Time-consuming for managers with little positive outcome

Our Alternative Approaches:

  • Collaborative problem-solving that maintains positive working relationships
  • Focus on identifying and addressing root behavioral causes, not just symptoms
  • Evidence-based solutions that actually improve performance
  • Clear, measurable goals with supportive feedback systems
  • Strategies that build employee confidence rather than create defensiveness
  • Environmental modifications that set employees up for success
  • Ongoing coaching and support rather than punitive documentation
  • Solutions that retain valuable talent while addressing specific concerns